There’s no spinning it, if Cam can’t go fans are justified to be stressed out. Even had Rose remained healthy, it sounds like Whittingham’s urge for smart and mistake-free football would have put Barnes as the fill-in for Cam.
The question is, which Barnes is Utah getting? Rose Bowl 2022 or Rose Bowl 2023 Barnes? Mop-up duty Barnes or Wazzu Barnes?
With time to prepare, he’s more than capable enough that fans should trust that he’ll be ready with a smart game plan by Ludwig. From there, it’s up to him to make the smart decisions. He won the Wazzu game by 4, but that’s a game Utah blows them out if Cam was in. That game wasn’t a good game. He made several questionable decisions throwing between the hash marks and the sidelines instead of hitting wide open guys over the middle. That was also his first ever collegiate extended action. I trust that he’s learned from that now and the coaches have drilled that in his head because if he tries those same throws against Florida, you can guarantee at least one pick-6.
If he is the QB, it’ll be a run-heavy approach. Quick passes can also probably eliminate his overthinking on surveying and making questionable throws.
The thing is, the talent is there with Barnes. If Cam can’t go, Barnes won’t be finding this out last minute. He’ll be prepared. It’s up to him to trust in and play within the game plan. If he does that, Utah will beat Florida. If he manages the game, takes what is given, and looks for the big play when it’s not forced, Utah will be in capable hands.