Natty what ifs
- By MUSSter Ute
- Inside Ute Nation
- 15 Replies
Watching the game last night, and reflecting on how we competed with UW this year (particularly in the first half), it made me think about hypotheticals.
I think our talent level, at least in the last 10 years, was highest in 2021. We had Cam, a healthy Kuithe, Covey, Kincaid, Tavion before his demons got to him, Bernard, Devin Lloyd, Tafua, a healthy Broughton, CPIII, Bishop, etc. If Ty Jordan doesn’t tragically die, does all that talent plus him have Utah win a national championship?
I’m not sure that we beat Georgia in either 2021 or 2022, but I think we do make the playoff in both of those years (if everyone hypothetically stays in 2022). In 2021, with Jordan returning, no way we lose to TDS or SDSU. We probably don’t lose to Oregon St either, which means we either go 12-0 or 11-1.
In 2022, with Jordan, we likely don’t lose to UF or at Oregon, 50-50 on the loss at UCLA, so probably 11-1, but maybe 12-0 too.
I think either the 2021 or 2022 team + Ty Jordan beats this year’s Michigan team, and maybe the 2021 team as it was constructed. For 2023, you could play the hypothetical of Cam and Kuithe being healthy, Ty deciding to come back for a 4th season, but then I feel like I’m really reaching.
Also, we probably don’t pick up Tavion if Ty doesn’t pass away, but then maybe JJ transitions to RB sooner (or maybe transfers sooner). Also, maybe the Charlie Brewer experiment lasts longer if Ty carries us through wins at TDS and at SDSU instead of losses, but I’ve got to think Cam wins out eventually.
As it is, 2021 was both tragic and magical, and 2022 was an amazing roller coaster ride, but it is also encouraging that our program was on the brink of the apex of cfb. Injuries largely derailed our 2023 hopes. The uncertainty of the transfer/NIL wild west gives me a bit of anxiety of if Utah can sustain or improve upon where we’ve been the last 3-5 years, but I still maintain that NIL is a huge opportunity for Utah if the fan base buys into it rather than handwringing and getting seduced with nostalgia.
I think our talent level, at least in the last 10 years, was highest in 2021. We had Cam, a healthy Kuithe, Covey, Kincaid, Tavion before his demons got to him, Bernard, Devin Lloyd, Tafua, a healthy Broughton, CPIII, Bishop, etc. If Ty Jordan doesn’t tragically die, does all that talent plus him have Utah win a national championship?
I’m not sure that we beat Georgia in either 2021 or 2022, but I think we do make the playoff in both of those years (if everyone hypothetically stays in 2022). In 2021, with Jordan returning, no way we lose to TDS or SDSU. We probably don’t lose to Oregon St either, which means we either go 12-0 or 11-1.
In 2022, with Jordan, we likely don’t lose to UF or at Oregon, 50-50 on the loss at UCLA, so probably 11-1, but maybe 12-0 too.
I think either the 2021 or 2022 team + Ty Jordan beats this year’s Michigan team, and maybe the 2021 team as it was constructed. For 2023, you could play the hypothetical of Cam and Kuithe being healthy, Ty deciding to come back for a 4th season, but then I feel like I’m really reaching.
Also, we probably don’t pick up Tavion if Ty doesn’t pass away, but then maybe JJ transitions to RB sooner (or maybe transfers sooner). Also, maybe the Charlie Brewer experiment lasts longer if Ty carries us through wins at TDS and at SDSU instead of losses, but I’ve got to think Cam wins out eventually.
As it is, 2021 was both tragic and magical, and 2022 was an amazing roller coaster ride, but it is also encouraging that our program was on the brink of the apex of cfb. Injuries largely derailed our 2023 hopes. The uncertainty of the transfer/NIL wild west gives me a bit of anxiety of if Utah can sustain or improve upon where we’ve been the last 3-5 years, but I still maintain that NIL is a huge opportunity for Utah if the fan base buys into it rather than handwringing and getting seduced with nostalgia.